Our department’s response to Coronavirus (COVID-19)
See Australia.gov.au for whole of Australian Government COVID-19 advice.
- Policies and initiatives
Emissions reduction
Industry innovation and science
- Artificial intelligence
- Australian Radioactive Waste Agency
- Australian Space Agency
- Boosting innovation and science
- Co-hosting the Square Kilometre Array
- Increasing international collaboration
- Industry growth centres
- Industry Innovation and Science Australia
- National Measurement Institute
- Optical astronomy in Australia
- Participating in the digital economy
- Promoting innovation precincts
- Science in our department
- Science, technology, engineering and mathematics (STEM)
Energy
Resources
Northern Australia
Trade
Business support
Measurement services
Government to government services
- Regulations and standards
Emissions reduction
Energy
Resources
- Applying to export rough diamonds
- Applying to export uranium and controlled ores
- Offshore mineral exploration and mining
- Offshore oil and gas exploration and development
- Offshore petroleum exploration acreage release process
- Regulating offshore oil and gas in Australian Commonwealth waters
- Regulating the Ranger Uranium Mine
- Taxes and royalties on minerals and petroleum
Measurement
Trade
Space industry
Building industry
Business support
- Funding and incentives
Emissions reduction
Industry innovation and science
- Australian Square Kilometre Array Fellowships Programme
- Business Research and Innovation Initiative
- Business-research collaboration
- Collaborating with Asia-Pacific on science, research and innovation
- Collaborating with China on science and research
- Collaborating with India on science and research
- Cooperative research centres
- Enabling international space investment
- Industry 4.0
- Inspiring Australia: Science engagement in Australia
- International research collaboration
- Moon to Mars: opportunities for Australian businesses
- Prime Minister's Prizes for Science
- Research and Development Tax Incentive
- Supporting advanced manufacturing
- Supporting business and innovation
- Supporting space infrastructure growth
- Transitioning Australia’s automotive manufacturing industry
- Venture capital
Resources
- About us
COVID-19
Jobs
Who we are
- Our Ministers
- Our Executive team
- Organisation chart
- Our portfolio agencies
- Overseas engagement
- Anti-Dumping Commission
- Anti-Dumping Review Panel
- Australian Radioactive Waste Agency
- Australian SKA Office
- Australian Space Agency
- Critical Minerals Facilitation Office
- National Measurement Institute
- Office of Innovation and Science Australia
- Office of Northern Australia
- Office of the Chief Economist
- Office of the Chief Scientist
Who we work with
Reporting and accountability
- Annual report
- Assurance and Audit Committee
- Budget statements
- Campaign Certification Statements
- Continuing Order of the Senate
- Corporate plan
- Deregulation agenda
- Freedom of information
- Gifts and benefits register
- Grants reporting
- Information Publication Scheme
- Our contracts
- Privacy impact assessments
- Public interest disclosure
- Senate Order 15: portfolio appointments and vacancies
Our online presence
Contact
- Publications
- News
- Policies and initiatives
Emissions reduction
Industry innovation and science
- Artificial intelligence
- Australian Radioactive Waste Agency
- Australian Space Agency
- Boosting innovation and science
- Co-hosting the Square Kilometre Array
- Increasing international collaboration
- Industry growth centres
- Industry Innovation and Science Australia
- National Measurement Institute
- Optical astronomy in Australia
- Participating in the digital economy
- Promoting innovation precincts
- Science in our department
- Science, technology, engineering and mathematics (STEM)
Energy
Resources
Northern Australia
Trade
Business support
Measurement services
Government to government services
- Regulations and standards
Emissions reduction
Energy
Resources
- Applying to export rough diamonds
- Applying to export uranium and controlled ores
- Offshore mineral exploration and mining
- Offshore oil and gas exploration and development
- Offshore petroleum exploration acreage release process
- Regulating offshore oil and gas in Australian Commonwealth waters
- Regulating the Ranger Uranium Mine
- Taxes and royalties on minerals and petroleum
Measurement
Trade
Space industry
Building industry
Business support
- Funding and incentives
Emissions reduction
Industry innovation and science
- Australian Square Kilometre Array Fellowships Programme
- Business Research and Innovation Initiative
- Business-research collaboration
- Collaborating with Asia-Pacific on science, research and innovation
- Collaborating with China on science and research
- Collaborating with India on science and research
- Cooperative research centres
- Enabling international space investment
- Industry 4.0
- Inspiring Australia: Science engagement in Australia
- International research collaboration
- Moon to Mars: opportunities for Australian businesses
- Prime Minister's Prizes for Science
- Research and Development Tax Incentive
- Supporting advanced manufacturing
- Supporting business and innovation
- Supporting space infrastructure growth
- Transitioning Australia’s automotive manufacturing industry
- Venture capital
Resources
- About us
COVID-19
Jobs
Who we are
- Our Ministers
- Our Executive team
- Organisation chart
- Our portfolio agencies
- Overseas engagement
- Anti-Dumping Commission
- Anti-Dumping Review Panel
- Australian Radioactive Waste Agency
- Australian SKA Office
- Australian Space Agency
- Critical Minerals Facilitation Office
- National Measurement Institute
- Office of Innovation and Science Australia
- Office of Northern Australia
- Office of the Chief Economist
- Office of the Chief Scientist
Who we work with
Reporting and accountability
- Annual report
- Assurance and Audit Committee
- Budget statements
- Campaign Certification Statements
- Continuing Order of the Senate
- Corporate plan
- Deregulation agenda
- Freedom of information
- Gifts and benefits register
- Grants reporting
- Information Publication Scheme
- Our contracts
- Privacy impact assessments
- Public interest disclosure
- Senate Order 15: portfolio appointments and vacancies
Our online presence
Contact
- Publications
- News
- Home
- Funding and incentives
- Industry innovation and science
- Prime Minister's prizes for science
- Prime Minister’s Prizes for Science Guidelines for Managing Diversity
On this page
Prime Minister’s Prizes for Science Guidelines for Managing Diversity

This guide outlines the measures taken to reduce the impact of implicit bias in the nomination and selection processes for the Prime Minister’s Prizes for Science. The guide is supplied to members of the selection committees prior to the assessment of nominations.
Background
The Prime Minister’s Prizes for Science are Australia’s most prestigious awards for outstanding achievements in scientific research, research-based innovation, and excellence in science teaching. The prizes recognise the achievements and success of Australian scientists and innovators, as well as the critical role science educators play in inspiring and encouraging students to take an interest in science and to consider science as a career. To ensure that the prizes truly recognise the most worthy nominees, it is important that the nomination and selection processes reflect the diversity of the communities being recognised. This includes ensuring the communities are empowered to identify and nominate diverse candidates, and that the selection processes are aligned with the latest best practice.
Implicit bias
Diversity in the recipients of recognition demonstrates a commitment to equity, and most selection committees strive for fairness in selecting prize winners. However, studies have shown that unconscious beliefs or assumptions – the phenomenon known as ‘implicit bias’ – can unintentionally influence judgement [1].
Research has shown that women do not receive scholarly recognition (awards and prizes for research) at a rate commensurate with their numbers in a discipline, or in line with the percentage of nominations [2]. While there are probably many factors contributing to this outcome, the research shows implicit bias is the most significant factor [3]. The following guidelines are intended to reduce subjectivity and minimise implicit bias in the nomination and judging process for the Prime Minister’s Prizes for Science and Science Teaching.
Committee members are required to review this briefing paper and other training resources provided by our department on managing implicit bias annually in advance of reviewing nominations.
Composition of the prize committees
Several recent studies demonstrate that more diverse groups with a greater breadth of perspectives make better decisions [4]. In addition, diverse committees provide access to a wider set of networks for cultivating nominations. The department will continue to ensure the Prime Minister’s Prizes committees are gender balanced in alignment with the government board diversity targets of 40/40/20, and encourage diversity in other aspects of the committees. It is expected that all committee members will advocate for diversity with it not just being the responsibility of committee members from under-represented groups.
Encouraging nominations
Promote a large and diverse pool of nominees
The Prime Minister’s Prize recipients are selected based on selection criteria outlined in the programme guidelines, so it is vital that the pool of nominees contains as many eligible candidates as possible. The department will promote the criteria and dates of the nomination period widely across multiple media channels, including social media and the department’s websites. In particular, the department will promote the Prizes directly to underrepresented groups and their associations using these methods and via email.
Periodic review of the eligibility guidelines
The department will review the eligibility guidelines annually to ensure that they remain current, and wherever possible eliminate any barriers to diverse nominations. This includes reviewing the language used in the guidelines, and the requirements for each individual prize against best practice.
Publicise the criteria and deadlines for the Prizes widely
The department will develop an annual communications plan aimed at increasing the awareness of the Prizes among the general community and the science sector. This has the added benefit of increasing interest in the Prizes and making the selection process more transparent and inclusive.
Selecting prize recipients
The following are guiding principles for the Prime Minister’s Prizes for Science and Science Teaching committees to reduce the effects of implicit bias in selecting prize recipients.
Discuss the process and criteria before reviewing nominations
Make sure your prioritised list of attributes matches the eligibility guidelines for the prize. Research has shown that implicit bias can enter via inadvertent “criteria shifting” after nominees are discussed.
List your personal top nominees before hearing the recommendations of others
This can help mitigate the undue influence of one member and ensure that the committee’s list of viable candidates will be as large as possible. Take the time to look carefully at each nomination, and select candidates for consideration because they meet the merit criteria, rather than finding reasons to eliminate candidates. Committee members will provide scores and ranking of nominees to the Prizes Secretariat ahead of the committee meetings and before discussions occur.
Ensure that every committee member’s voice is heard
Budget adequate time to make a decision and moderate selection discussions to include all members. Studies show that implicit bias is lessened when committees have time for thoughtful reflection and discussion.
Avoid perceived and actual conflicts of interest
Committee members should make clear any connection with a person under consideration for an award so that the committee can come to a decision with respect to participation in further discussions.
If a committee member is nominated for a prize they must step down from the committee if they wish to pursue the nomination. Support letters should not come from members of the Prize committees. Members of the Prize committees should not prepare individual nominations; however they should actively recruit nominations for individuals they feel would be competitive for the award.
A member of the Prize Committees may find that they are in a potential conflict of interest situation with respect to a particular nominee, because of an existing or former relationship with the nominee of a professional or personal nature; in such a situation, the member shall disclose the nature of the potential conflict of interest to the Committee Chair at the earliest opportunity and the Committee Chair shall then consult with the programme delegate on how to proceed.
Footnotes
- [1] Women in STEM Careers: International Perspectives on Increasing Workforce participation, Advancement and Leadership: Chapter 9, Professional societies and gender equity in STEM.
- [2] The Matilda Effect in science: awards and prizes in the US, 1990s and 2000s. Anne E. Lincoln, Stephanie Pincus, Janet Bandows Koster and Phoebe S. Leboy, Social Studies of Science 2012 42:307.
- [3] Does Gender Bias Influence Awards Given by Societies? Mary Anne Holmes, Pranoti Asher, John Farrington, Rana Fine, Margaret S. Leinen, Phoebe LeBoy, Eos Trans. AGU, 92(47),421.
- [4] Women in STEM Careers: International Perspectives on Increasing Workforce participation, Advancement and Leadership: Chapter 9, Professional societies and gender equity in STEM.
Read more
Read more about the Prime Minister’s Prizes for Science
Contact us
Email pmprizes@industry.gov.au
Last updated: 8 December 2020
Content ID: 65854